The Legal Beat
Weird How Quiet The ‘Campus Free Speech Crisis’ Crowd Has Been About CUNY Law School
Posted on Friday June 02, 2023
Graduation at CUNY Law earned a little more coverage than usual this year. Graduate speaker Fatima Mohammed covered a lot of the usual ground, reminiscing about major events over the last three years and encouraging classmates to go out and fight for their clients. But, since this is CUNY, the big events included a student government resolution to boycott Israel over treatment of Palestinians and those clients are victims of NYPD violence so the speech got a lot of folks angry.
From the Chronicle of Higher Education:
While the ceremony was held almost three weeks ago, the furor sparked by her speech has grown in recent days as a video circulated on social media. A New York Post headline described her speech as “hate-filled” and Fox News’s headline deemed it “vile.” U.S. Rep. Daniel Goldman, a Democrat who represents New York’s 10th district, condemned the law student’s “hateful and misleading rhetoric” in a tweet.
New York City Mayor Eric Adams took to the media to blast the speech. The Board of Trustees issued a statement branding it hate speech too.
This all can be fine. It’s how free speech works — people say things and if you disagree you can protest them. If the individual Trustees wanted to boo her in the middle of her speech that’s generally within their rights. Up until the point where government figures start directly or indirectly seeking to stifle speech. That’s where things get constitutionally ugly.
Now, a GOP legislator is introducing a bill to strip the school of funding over the incident. It’s really weird that Rep. Lawler announced this on Fox News, because the last time I checked they were very, very concerned about free speech on campus.
And that’s the whole trick, isn’t it? After months of breathless meltdowns over campus free speech with federal judge boycotts, student doxxing, new snitching campaigns, and some downright embarrassing “heckler’s veto” discourse, the usual suspects in the campus free speech game have fallen curiously silent.
Whatever one thinks of this specific speech is irrelevant. In fact, the silence is even more damning if you do think the CUNY address crosses into hate speech. Because the Washington Free Beacon, Fox News, Newsmax ecosphere could not shut up about how precious it is to protect recognized hate groups from even the mildest rebuke for over a year, but none of those outlets seem all that concerned by the prospect of the federal government defunding a public institution over the content of a student speech.
I guess only certain brands of hate speech need to be nurtured from criticism.
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news. Joe also serves as a Managing Director at RPN Executive Search.
ADDITIONAL STORIES:
You’re Named After Who? This Top Law School Will Have To Fight For Its New Name
Posted on Friday June 09, 2023
Law Students Are Reluctant To Use ChatGPT, Survey Finds. The Question Is, Why?
Posted on Thursday June 08, 2023
A New Law School Reigns Supreme In The U.S. News Law School Omnibus Specialty Rankings
Posted on Tuesday June 06, 2023
‘Do Your Research,’ ‘Stick It Out,’ And Other Things Law Schools Should Stop Telling Students About Clerkships
Posted on Tuesday June 06, 2023
Bar Exam Prep Company Goes Down For The Day… Please Don’t Panic
Posted on Tuesday June 06, 2023
Weird How Quiet The ‘Campus Free Speech Crisis’ Crowd Has Been About CUNY Law School
Posted on Friday June 02, 2023
Jonathan Turley Rewrites Constitution To Include ‘Congressional Backsies’ Clause
Posted on Friday June 02, 2023
GRE Building A Better Test… But Is It Still A Good Test For Law Schools?
Posted on Wednesday May 31, 2023
Jonathan Turley Has New Theory To Bust Hunter Biden And All It Requires Is Warping The Fabric Of Space-Time
Posted on Wednesday May 31, 2023
The Black Guide To Law School Rankings Are Out… With A Twist
Posted on Tuesday May 30, 2023
Harvard Law School Professor Wants ‘State Power’ To Exact ‘Sting Of Political Enmity’ On Baseball Team Over Pride Night
Posted on Friday May 26, 2023
Major Changes To The Bar Exam Are On Their Way
Posted on Thursday May 25, 2023
BARBRI Teaches Most Important Lesson Of Being A Young Lawyer: Dealing With Passive-Aggressive People
Posted on Wednesday May 24, 2023
Woke Mob Rewriting The Bar Exam Or Something, According To Judge
Posted on Monday May 22, 2023
Is The Witness In The Room With Us? Well… Kinda?
Posted on Monday May 22, 2023