The Legal Beat
Columbia Law Professors Respond To University’s Police Crackdowns On Campus Free Speech
Posted on Wednesday April 24, 2024
We’ve recently seen several less-than-stellar responses from respected academic institutions that have been justified on the grounds that they did what they did to maintain “free speech”: Stanford’s response to Kyle Duncan’s inability to justify his positions to students and Amy Wax spewing PragerU talking points come to mind. Not to be undone by its cohort, Columbia responded to largely peaceful protests by calling the cops on their students and suspending them en masse. In response, several of Columbia’s law professors banded together to share their disappointment in Columbia’s response:
Leave it to law professors to be right on the mark when it comes to faulting an institution for failing to adhere to procedure! It is hard to justify blanket suspensions because of unspecified policies unless, of course, you get to jettison staples of justice like due process when people start saying things you don’t like. Notice is, after all, a key component of due process. You could make the argument that people are still beholden to undisclosed laws and punishments, but I’d also doubt you’d fare well in either Constitutional or Criminal Law. Frankly, it is harder to make the point better than the law professors did:
Procedural irregularity, a lack of transparency about the university’s decision making, and the extraordinary involvement of the NYPD all threaten the university’s legitimacy within its own community and beyond its gates. We urge the university to conform student discipline to clear and well-established procedures that respect the rule of law.
It is also worth noting that Columbia’s response probably won’t go over too well in due time. This isn’t the only time that a major Columbia protest looked like this:
It looked a lot like this back in 1968 when Columbia students were protesting the war in Vietnam:
Back then, the university’s punishments were relatively tame compared to how they’ve responded this time:
So much for speaking your mind on campus.
Chris Williams became a social media manager and assistant editor for Above the Law in June 2021. Prior to joining the staff, he moonlighted as a minor Memelord™ in the Facebook group Law School Memes for Edgy T14s. He endured Missouri long enough to graduate from Washington University in St. Louis School of Law. He is a former boatbuilder who cannot swim, a published author on critical race theory, philosophy, and humor, and has a love for cycling that occasionally annoys his peers. You can reach him by email at [email protected] and by tweet at @WritesForRent.
ADDITIONAL STORIES:
5 Reasons Why Law Students Chose Their Law School
Posted on Thursday April 25, 2024
The Top Law Schools For Getting Jobs (2023)
Posted on Thursday April 25, 2024
This Comedian’s Legal Career Is Her Best Joke
Posted on Wednesday April 24, 2024
Time Is Running Out: Send Your Entries ASAP For ATL’s 15th Annual Law Revue Video Contest!
Posted on Wednesday April 24, 2024
Don’t Call It A Comeback For Cooley Law School… Because It’s Probably Not A Comeback
Posted on Wednesday April 24, 2024
Columbia Law Professors Respond To University’s Police Crackdowns On Campus Free Speech
Posted on Wednesday April 24, 2024
At Some Law Schools, The Role Of Dean Has Always Been A Man’s Job
Posted on Tuesday April 23, 2024
Elite Law School Reigns Supreme In The U.S. News Law School Omnibus Specialty Rankings
Posted on Tuesday April 23, 2024
Submit Entries ASAP For Above The Law’s 15th Annual Law Revue Video Contest
Posted on Monday April 22, 2024
Submission Deadline Approaching: Above The Law’s 15th Annual Law Revue Video Contest
Posted on Friday April 19, 2024
Law School Brings Serious BDE (Big Diploma Energy)
Posted on Wednesday April 17, 2024
Send In Those Submissions For Above The Law’s 15th Annual Law Revue Video Contest!
Posted on Tuesday April 16, 2024
Law Schools Are Bringing Out Big Names As 2024 Graduation Speakers
Posted on Tuesday April 16, 2024
Before Alvin Bragg Became The Symbol Of Trump Accountability…
Posted on Monday April 15, 2024
U.S. News Law School Rankings Makes Its Smartest Methodological Change: Telling Holdout Schools To Suck It
Posted on Monday April 15, 2024