Brief Fact Summary. Petitioners Shelley, who were black, bought a home in a neighborhood in which thirty out of thirty-nine parcel owners had signed a restrictive covenant which stated that no home was to be sold to any person who was black, which led to the suit by the neighborhood to undo the sale of the property to Shelley.
Synopsis of Rule of Law. The Fourteenth Amendment’s guarantee of equal protection applies in this case to prohibit the enforcement of the restrictive covenant at issue due to the fact that the provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment apply only where there is state action, which is found in this case due to the action of the Supreme Court of Missouri in enforcing the agreement, the result of which is to deprive the Petitioners of their property.
Issue. Does the action of the state court in enforcing the restrictive covenant deprive Petitioner of rights guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment and acts of Congress?
Held. Yes. The judgment of the Supreme Court of Missouri is reversed.
First, the Court noted prior decisions and found that the restrictive agreements, standing alone, could not be regarded as a violation of any Fourteenth Amendment rights. The Court found that the requirement for state action was not met in a purely private and voluntary covenant. However, the Court found that in this case there was state action by virtue of the Supreme Court of Missouri’s decision to enforce the restrictive covenant. The Court found that state action includes actions by legislative bodies and also courts and judicial officials.
The Court held that in granting judicial sanction to an agreement which, by its terms, would deprive the Petitioners of equal protections guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment is an action which cannot stand. Therefore, the Court held that the Supreme Court of Missouri had to be reversed. Because the Court decided the case on the question of equal protection it was unnecessary to consider the Petitioner’s arguments regarding due process and whether the Petitioners had been denied privileges and immunities accorded to citizens of the United States.
The rights established are personal rights.View Full Point of Law