CaseCast™ – "What you need to know"
Brief Fact Summary. The Defendant, Hilton Hotels Corp. (Defendant), was involved in an association in Portland that collectively agreed to give preferential treatment to suppliers who contributed money to the association. Though it was against corporate policy for the Defendant corporation to be involved in such a scheme, a purchasing agent for the corporation threatened a loss of business to suppliers if they did not contribute to the association.
Synopsis of Rule of Law. A corporation is criminally liable for the acts of its agents in the scope of their employment, even where agents have acted against the express policy of the corporation.
Issue. Is a corporation criminally liable under the Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C. Section:1 (the Act), for actions taken by its agents in the scope of their authority, but counter to corporate policy?
Held. Yes. Judgment affirmed.
It is appropriate to hold the corporation liable for the acts of the individual agent because insomuch as the Act violations are commercial offenses, it is the corporation that will profit from the illegal activity and not the agent himself. Violation of the Act are in fact typically the result of pressure to maximize profits, leading individual agents to go against a general corporate policy for the sake of enhancing the profits of the corporation.
Corporate liability for violation of the Act is appropriate on account of the generally complex business structures through which a violation occurs, making it difficult to identify the particular agents that were involved in the unlawful activity. Even where the agents are identified and prosecuted, it is ineffective as a deterrent as no consequences would befall the corporation itself.
Discussion. This case represents a further step taken in law to hold corporations accountable for their unlawful actions, even when done by an agent acting against corporate policy and procedures. It attempts to maximize the deterrent effect by encouraging corporations to be more diligent in supervising the business activities of its agents done on behalf of the corporation.