Brief Fact Summary.
Yania (Plaintiff) drowned when he jumped into a hole filled with water at Bigan’s (Defendant’s) coal strip-mining operation.
Synopsis of Rule of Law.
Unless there a person is legally responsible for placing a person in harm’s way, there is no duty to rescue the person.
Every material and relevant fact well pleaded in the complaint and every inference fairly deducible therefrom are to be taken as true.View Full Point of Law
Bigan (Defendant) ran a coal strip-mining operation where he had large holes in the ground filled with water. Yania (Plaintiff) came to discuss business dealings with Defendant. Defendant asked Plaintiff for his help in turning on a water pump that was in one of the holes. Yania jumped into the water from a high height, at Bigan’s goading, and drowned.
Did Defendant have a duty to rescue Plaintiff after goading him into jumping into the water?
No, the Court held Defendant had no duty to rescue Plaintiff. The Court affirmed the trial court’s order granting Defendant’s demurrers.