Register | Lost your password?


Osborne v. McMasters

View this case and other resources at:
Bloomberg Law

Citation. 73 Fed. Appx. 418, 2003 U.S. App.

Brief Fact Summary. A woman died as a result of ingesting poison from an unlabeled bottle purchased at the Defendant, McMaster’s (Defendant) drug store. The Defendant was required by law to label all poisons.

Synopsis of Rule of Law. If a person neglects to perform a duty imposed by either statute or common law and that law is designed for the protection of others, then the evidence of the act or omission constitutes negligence per se.

Facts. A clerk working in the Defendant’s drug store sold an unlabeled bottle of poison to the Plaintiff, Osborne’s (Plaintiff) wife. Not knowing that the drug was poisonous, the Plaintiff’s wife took the drug and died. By statute the clerk was required to label the drug as poison and by failing to do so, he broke the law.

Issue. Whether the Defendant was negligent in failing to abide by the statutory requirement to label all poisons.

Comments are closed.